Clarifying the Controversial Slide: Waterbury Clemente vs Southington Showdown

A blown call by Home Plate Umpire in Simsbury Game goes against WTBY.

In a tense and closely contested game yesterday vs Southington the Waterbury Roberto Clemente team faced another crucial ruling on a slide play that didn’t go their way ( as seen below from the previous game) But this time the call has sparked conversation among fans and coaches alike as WTBY suffered their 1st loss of Summer.

The play in question involved a Waterbury runner sliding while the ball was still in motion from the outfield, having just reached the cutoff man but not yet arrived at the fielder involved in the tag attempt. This timing is key to understanding the controversial call.

According to Little League Rule 7.08(a)(3), a runner is required to either slide or attempt to avoid a fielder who has possession of the ball and is waiting to make a tag. In this instance, because the ball had not yet reached the fielder and was still en route via the cutoff, the defender did not have the ball at the time of the slide. This crucial detail suggests that the runner’s slide could be viewed as legal, as the rule applies only when the fielder is in possession of the ball and ready to make a tag.

Furthermore, the rule does not require a mandatory slide; it requires the runner to either slide or make a visible attempt to avoid contact with the fielder once the ball is in their control. When the ball is still arriving, the runner is not obligated to slide or evade since no immediate tag attempt can be made.

That said, baseball is often a game of split-second decisions and “bang-bang” plays, where timing is razor-thin and officials must make calls in real-time. The umpire crew may have interpreted the slide as interfering with the play or judged that the runner failed to avoid the fielder properly, leading to the out call.

Want more Clemente Allstar News?

From Waterbury’s perspective, the slide was a clean, timely attempt to advance aggressively—a hallmark of competitive baserunning. The close nature of the play emphasizes the high level of competition and intensity in the league.

In summary, while the rules suggest the runner could have been considered safe given the ball’s position, the instantaneous judgment required by umpires and the tight timing frame made the call extremely close. Both teams demonstrated skill and determination, with this play highlighting the thrilling, fast-paced nature of Little League baseball.

The Clemente All Stars now sit and wait for Wednesday for a chance to bounce back and claim another title this Summer.

3 responses to “Clarifying the Controversial Slide: Waterbury Clemente vs Southington Showdown”

  1. […] you’re penalizing a 12-year-old for a borderline slide possibly misapplying a rule in a bang-bang play while the ball is still in the outfield—in a game […]

    Like

  2. […] And it was Clemente’s first loss but not without some questionable interpretation of the rules […]

    Like

Leave a comment