Are Hit-and-Run Drivers Getting Off Easy in Waterbury? Two Dead, One in a Coma, Less Than 8 Years Behind Bars

By D.M.Livingston

Published Nov 16, 2025

Update: Nov 16 2025 7:11PM-

correction

( John Egan hit and run did not result in a death, as an editing error has been corrected)

WATERBURY, CT — Waterbury has seen three tragic hit-and-run crashes in recent years. Two lives were lost, one victim left in a coma, yet the drivers responsible served shockingly short jail sentences.

In May 2023John Egan, 58, left Bryan Calle, a teenager in critical condition after a crash, resulting in a coma. He pleaded nolo contendere to evading responsibility causing serious physical injury. Egan was sentenced to 10 years in jail, with execution suspended after 2 years, and 5 years of probation.

John Egan ( 2 years )

In March 2024Christine Mcweeney , 58, pleaded guilty to evading responsibility resulting in death following a fatal crash where Christopher “Figgs” Coleman. She was sentenced to 3 years in jail and 5 years of probation.

Christine Mcweeney (3 years)

Then in May 2024Trae Christopher Pratt, 22, struck and killed Dwayne Hunter. Pratt pleaded guilty to second-degree manslaughter and evading responsibility resulting in death, receiving 2 years and 6 months in jail plus 5 years of probation.

Trae Pratt (2.5 years)

Combined, these three crashes resulted in less than 8 years of actual jail time for two deaths and one victim left in a coma. All three drivers fled the scene, yet the penalties are light compared to the lives affected.

Waterbury residents are asking tough questions: Are prosecutors holding hit-and-run drivers accountable Are Connecticut courts sending the right message about fleeing the scene and causing death or serious injury?

These cases highlight a troubling pattern in Connecticut: fatal and serious hit-and-run cases are often met with sentences that do not match the severity of the crime. The victims’ families continue to live with permanent loss and trauma, while the drivers serve only a fraction of their sentences behind bars.

Lawmakers in Hartford should consider reviewing and strengthening penalties for hit-and-run drivers, ensuring that fleeing the scene of a fatal or serious injury crash carries consequences that reflect the gravity of the act.

To the friends and families of Bryan Calle, Dwayne Hunter, and Christopher Coleman, the community stands with you. Your loss and trauma are real, and the hope is that justice will evolve to better protect victims and prevent future tragedies.

💬 We want to hear from you: Should Hartford lawmakers pass stricter penalties for drivers who flee serious or fatal accidents? Share your thoughts below.

The Waterbury Times is a locally owned civic newsroom committed to accurate, ethical, and community-centered reporting. As a member of the Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ), we follow strict standards of verification and transparency to keep Waterbury informed.

For more local updates, visit our Homepage or follow us on social.

9 responses to “Are Hit-and-Run Drivers Getting Off Easy in Waterbury? Two Dead, One in a Coma, Less Than 8 Years Behind Bars”

  1. should have to spend the whole time sentenced. I guess you kill people with your car in Waterbury & suffer minor consequences.
    judges are idiots most of the time.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. no one was killed in the Egan hit and run. He needs to fact check his article. Only 16yr old Bryan Calle was fatally injured in the hit and run.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you for reading our articles. You are correct. Should have read , a teenager, not and a teenager. We have corrected the incorrect wordings on the article as well. John Egan did not cost anyone their life

        Like

  2. hey not trying to be rude but need to edit article. There was only one victim in the John Egan hit and run. You wrote he killed one and injured another but the only victim in hit and run was Bryan Calle who he did fatally and critically injure him for the rest of his life.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. need to fact check. Only one victim in Egan hit and run. Bryan Calle was only victim who was fatally and critically injured for the rest of his life but no one was killed. Not trying to be a dick or stand up for the guy but wanted to point that out. Ty

    Like

  4. need to fact check. Only one victim in Egan hit and run. Bryan Calle was only victim who was fatally and critically injured for the rest of his life but no one was killed. Not trying to be a dick or stand up for the guy but wanted to point that out. Ty

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for reading our articles. You are correct. Should have read ( a teenager) not and a teenager and we corrected the editing mistake. John Egan did not take anyone’s life

      Like

  5. As a victim of a near fatal hit and run in Waterbury in January 2010… I have a lot to say about this whole topic.. I survived with a fractured pelvis, fractured skull, broken jaw, broken nasal passageway, multiple broken bones and several lacerations… The man who hit me served basically no time despite having prior gun related charges and being on probation… I have to live with my scars and trauma FOR LIFE, the victims are the only ones who suffer. People stare at my scars daily, some will ask kindly, others will look at me and laugh (not realizing half my face is scarred and instead thinking I have “makeup smeared all over my face”?!). I’ve even had a few people make jokes to my face… Yet I’m grateful to GOD that I survived when things could have been very different. Despite everything I feel, I try to remain positive and look at my scars as strength.

    Like

Leave a reply to D.M. Livingston Cancel reply